On the night of March 16-17 1941, with well over 100 passengers aboard, the Pennsylvania Railroad’s Buckeye Limited leaped from the tracks near Baden and plunged into the frigid Ohio River.
Witnesses rushed to save the victims from cars scattered along the Beaver County riverbank. Officials later released the tally: Five people were dead, including an infant and three railroad employees, and more than 100 were injured.
Within days, investigators revealed disturbing details: Someone had removed spikes and shifted a 39-foot section of rail. Two figures were spotted watching the tracks through a blinding snowstorm. Dozens of visiting Soviet officials — the purpose of their visit unclear — had ridden the Manhattan Limited along the same spot just minutes before. And FBI investigators, it seems, considered American Trotskyists as potential suspects — suggesting they targeted the Soviet officials but destroyed the wrong train.